In a message dated 09/07/2008 12:21:22 GMT Standard Time,
nabokv-l@UTK.EDU (Don Stanley)
writes:
Further
to Nabokov and Freud:
A great American writer named Charles Bukowski
probably could have used a little professional therapy, but shared Nabokov’s
disdain. Bukowski’s line was something like, “The psychiatrists have a word
for people like me. And I have a word for the
psychiatrists.”
Freud was not a psychiatrist. He was a neurologist (i.e., a real doctor)
who developed a form of conversation (i.e., a non-medical discipline) that is
independent of his, or anyone's, medical knowledge. This discipline,
although open to abuse, is potentially of great value. As Freud himself
insisted, it is not part of medicine. Nor is it part of the pseudo-medical
enterprise called "psychiatry". Disdain based on ignorance of the most
elementary and easily ascertainable data is itself deserving of disdain.
Anthony Stadlen