NABOKV-L post 0018671, Thu, 15 Oct 2009 23:24:26 -0300

Re: [ NABOKOV-L] [SIGHTING] favorite characters and novels
J.Aisenberg: "Speaking of Lolita and Allen..., in his film Manhattan, a scene where he and his girl ...walk down a street talking, Keaton's character declares thinks Allen's going out with a teen is Nabokovian; her boyfriend declares him a candidate for most over rated artists of all time. I guess that's a sighting. Watch it here at youtube."

JM: Unfortunately the youtube instructions came out muddled for me.

I was curious to confirm if the "over rated artist" in the transcribed dialogue refers to a Woody Allen's momentary self-mockery, or to Nabokov himself.
Allen might have read E.Wilson's angry criticism of Nabokov's "Eugene Onegin" translation ( NYBR 1965). In this case, the choice for "over rated" might enter as a kind of highbrow "quote"...*

* Wilson noted, about VN, that "his speaking of the eclogues of 'the overrated Virgil' as 'stale imitations of the idyls of Theocritus'..." would be "the result of his instinct to take digs at great reputations... Balzac's "La Femme de Trente ans" is a "much overrated vulgar novelette." Dostoevsky is identified as "a much overrated, sentimental, and Gothic novelist of the time"..." Le Rouge et le Noir, also, is "much overrated" ...

Search archive with Google:

Contact the Editors:,
Visit Zembla:
View Nabokv-L policies:
Visit "Nabokov Online Journal:"

Manage subscription options: